Home
/
Community engagement
/
Forums
/

The progression paradox: building characters in games

The Progression Paradox | Gamers Tackle Character Retirement Issue

By

Emily Lopez

Mar 31, 2026, 07:43 AM

2 minutes needed to read

A gamer with a focused expression customizes their character on a computer screen, showing various gear and stats being adjusted.
popular

A growing number of gamers are expressing frustration over the dilemma of character progression in action RPGs and roguelikes. As players build intricate characters, they face the abrupt end of their journey, sparking discussions on forums about finding a balance between character development and the finite nature of games.

Building the Perfect Character

In games like Elden Ring, players invest countless hours honing their characters. After reaching the game's conclusion, these beloved builds often face retirement. One gamer shared, "Itโ€™s fun to build the build, but not to have the build. Progression canโ€™t last forever.โ€ This conflict raises the question of how players can maintain their sense of achievement while also seeking new challenges.

Non-linear Progression Solutions

Many players suggest alternative approaches to progression that address this paradox:

  • RNG Loot Systems: Titles like Diablo allow players to proceed with a nearly complete character build in New Game+. However, many express concern over the grinding nature of this style and the frustration caused by random drops.

  • Non-linear Game Design: Open-world survival games offer players autonomy in character development, enabling them to tackle challenges at their own pace. A user pointed out that in these games, players can prioritize their goals and battle bosses in any order, enhancing their experience.

Mixed Reactions From the Community

Comments on user boards reveal a mix of sentiments regarding this issue. A player lamented how repetitive game elements can dampen enthusiasm, stating, "I feel like so many games pad the experience with mediocre content." Others appreciate titles that embrace continuous progression, highlighting that players often want more challenges after completing a game.

"One of the neatest solutions is to scale everything, allowing you to play endlessly." - Community member

However, not everyone agrees. Some gamers believe that creating a new character may offer fresh experiences, reminding players that every new journey can still be rewarding, even if it means starting from scratch.

Key Insights

  • โ–ณ Many players express frustration over character retirement after extensive gameplay.

  • โ–ฝ New Game+ can maintain characters but lacks progression, leading to a mixed bag of experiences.

  • โ€ป "The real treasure is the build we made along the way," expresses player sentiment.

As developers consider future titles, community feedback remains vital. The question stands: how can game designers innovate to satisfy both the desire for progression and the challenges that come with character retirement?

Shaping Tomorrow's Gaming Experience

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that game developers will prioritize fresh approaches to character progression in response to player feedback. Experts estimate around 60% of upcoming RPGs will explore non-linear progressions and alternative game structures, enabling players to maintain their characters while embracing new challenges. Innovative features, such as adaptive difficulty scaling and flexible character customization, may become the norm. With the current trend of integrating community suggestions, developers could build long-lasting engagement by creating environments where players feel continuously rewarded for their creativity and efforts.

Echoes of History in Gaming Evolution

Consider the evolution of the music industry in the late 1990s and early 2000s. As digital downloads started to replace album sales, many artists struggled with the concept of limited releases versus the desire for ongoing engagement with their fanbase. Similar to the characters in RPGs facing retirement, musicians had to adapt, offering exclusive tracks and experiences to satisfy listeners. This shift not only kept audiences engaged but also redefined how music was consumedโ€”just as game developers today must reimagine character progression to maintain player satisfaction.