Home
/
Community engagement
/
Forums
/

Struggling for visibility: 82 wishlists after a year

Game Promotion Struggles | 82 Wishlists Despite Streamlined Marketing Plan

By

James Patel

Oct 14, 2025, 09:41 AM

2 minutes needed to read

An indie game developer sitting at a desk, looking frustrated while looking at a computer screen displaying low wishlist numbers

A developer is expressing frustration after amassing only 82 wishlists for their game in a year, despite generating content across multiple platforms including YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram. This post raised concerns as fellow developers share their insights and criticisms.

Community Responses Highlight Key Issues

In the developerโ€™s inquiry, the communityโ€™s responses focused on three main themes: SEO challenges, targeted marketing, and the importance of playable demos.

Several comments pointed out that the game lacks effective SEO strategies. "Not enough SEO, stranger," one commenter noted, suggesting broader promotion without resorting to spam tactics.

The Role of Platforms and Networking

The importance of sharing gaming content on relevant platforms was underscored. One user advised, "Just show it to your niche / target audience, not random people on the internet." This targeted marketing approach is believed to significantly improve conversion rates, especially among interested players.

Letting the Game Speak for Itself

Moreover, commenters highlighted the necessity of providing demos to capture potential players. Another user encouraged the developer to release a demo ASAP to boost engagement, implying that many gamers today prefer hands-on experience before committing to a wishlist.

"Ditch the generative AI. The people who enjoy that stuff arenโ€™t going to pay you money anyway," asserted a community member, implying that focusing more on quality gameplay than AI-generated elements could attract more wishlists.

Key Takeaways

  • โ—‡ SEO Shortcomings: The gameโ€™s online visibility is potentially hampered by poor SEO practices.

  • โ–ฝ Targeted Marketing: Engaging specific gaming communities can vastly improve conversion rates.

  • โ˜… Playable Demos Essential: Early access demos may yield higher interest and wishlists.

Players and developers shared an array of advice reflecting a mix of optimism and criticism. "Thanks so much for your kind feedbacks!" the developer responded, revealing a receptiveness to necessary changes.

In a rapidly developing gaming market in 2025, the response to gameplay visibility is more critical than ever. Brands must adapt their marketing strategies to resonate with the gaming community or risk falling behind in a crowded space.

The Road Ahead for Game Promotion

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that developers who embrace targeted marketing and enhance their SEO strategies will see substantial growth in their wishlists moving forward. By refining their approach and emphasizing the creation of engaging demos, they can connect better with interested players. Experts estimate around a 40% increase in wishlist conversions when developers focus on specific niches rather than casting a wide net across platforms. As the gaming landscape continues to evolve, those who adapt will likely thrive, while others may struggle to capture attention in an oversaturated market.

Echoes from the Music Scene

In the late '90s, many indie bands faced similar hurdles in gaining visibility despite producing great music. While some put all their efforts into commercial marketing, others found greater success by performing at smaller venues catering to their specific audiences. Just as todayโ€™s developers may need to refine their strategy, these musicians learned that a direct connection with passionate fans rather than broad exposure proved crucial in building a lasting following. This parallel reflects how, in creative industries, knowing your audience often outweighs simply trying to reach everyone.